Re: Can Vlookup return multiple values?
Hi Dom --
First of all, I'm slow. I didn't know you'd responded to my private message; I assumed I'd received an e-mail notice once you responded, but I didn't. And OK, I'll try to keep it on the board.
Attached is our back and forth winnings2.xls file with a few more clarifications you'll understand I hope. But first read what I've written below.
Quote from Domenic
Yeah, I know that the numbers I plugged in may not have made quite sense, but I used them for testing purposes.
Understood.
Don't worry about the dough just yet. That will be the easy part once we take care of the ranking.
Understood.
So I take it that Scott Butler, who's next in the ranking order and ranks 2nd gets $3,000.
No, Scott Butler would then receive 2nd place money ($6000) in Gross, since Anderson no longer counts in the gross division. Anderson is paid in the Net division where he wins more than by splitting 1st and 2nd dough with Christopher in the Gross. And yes, Christopher now wins Gross 1st place alone.
What if Jeff Cook is tied with Scott with a Gross Score of 76 and ranks 3rd?
Lets assume Jeff's Gross is 76, BUT that his handicap is 7 instead of 9, thus leaving his Net score at 69. In this instance, Jeff would tie Scott and split 2nd and 3rd dough gross ($6000 + $3000 = $9000 / 2 = $4500 each) which is the Highest Finish and Dough possible for Jeff, who would otherwise finish with 3rd money ($4000) in Net with his 69.
Also, what if, instead, Jeff keeps his score of 78?
Per the attached file, he wins 3rd Net.
I take it, the same princples would apply to Net Scores. For example, if some else were tied for 1st place with Rich Anderson, they'd be splitting the sum of $12,000 + $8,000, which would give them $10,000 each. And, in this case, Rich Anderson would be comparing his winnings in Gross Score ($9,000) with his winnings in Net Score ($10,000), and still receive first place in Net, right?
Correct.
Also, what if six people are tied for 1st place in Gross and none have placed in Net? And what happens to those who rank 2nd and 3rd?
Display More
All who tied for 1st split 1st, 2nd and 3rd prize: $12,000 + $6000 + $3000 = $21000 / 6 = $3500 each. And those who rank 2nd and 3rd in Net win nothing (because they really place 7th and 8th).
OK Next: Pursuant to your question to explain precedence for Highest Finish (the terminology should say Highest $ Finish) here goes --
1) Highest available prize is first precedent. (if 1st Gross pays $10,000 and 1st Net pays $12,000, and one person places 1st in both categories, he would win 1st Place Net and receive 1st Place Net prize money. If the next highest prize is 1st Gross, then next lowest Gross score wins 1st Gross prize.)
2) If places (1st, 2nd, 3rd etc) pay the same in both gross and net, then Gross finish takes precedence over Net finish.
(e.g. in our Winnings2.xls worksheet, if Anderson HAD NOT been tied by Christopher in Gross, Anderson would have placed 1st in BOTH Gross and Net divisions, yet would have won 1st Place Gross and been paid 1st Place money in Gross and nothing in Net.)
3) Next, if 1st 2nd 3rd etc in Gross and Net pay the same amount, once 1st Place Gross is determined, 1st Place Net is then the next highest available prize, so the lowest net score is next determined and awarded this prize. If no ties exist, 1st Net is awarded, and then the next precedent would be back to determine 2nd Gross. If ties exist, however: a) if none of those who tie would place in Gross, how ever many tie split total amount due that many places (4 tie = equally split 1st, 2nd, 3rd and 4th place dough) b) if one of those who tie for 1st Net would win Gross 2nd alone which would pay more than 1/4 of sum of 1st thru 4th money in net, that person receives Gross 2nd (his highest finish available) and the other 3 then split the sum of 1st, 2nd and 3rd Net.
So, we have now awarded Gross: 1st, 2nd; and in Net: 1st, 2nd, 3rd (who all tied). Next highest available prize is 3rd Gross, so the next lowest Gross score wins 3rd place. But again if there are ties for 3rd Place Gross, and if one or more of those who tie would place in the Net division and win more than the winnings they'd receive by splitting 3rd, 4th, 5th whatever places etc in the gross division, they then go back to the Net payout.
Another factor which can serve to further confuse the Highest $ Finish determination is the fact that most tournaments pay more Net places than Gross places, since the actual Gross “field,” in reality, is much smaller than the Net “field.” Although all players are considered “entered” in both the Gross and Net divisions, only the best players in the field truly have a chance in the Gross division. (e.g. A 24 handicapper is never going to shoot a score which will earn him a “place” in the gross (handicap doesn’t count) division. See what I mean?)
Clear as mud? Whistle if I've not made myself clear. Hopefully the attached file will again help.
And once again, thank you thank you thank you in advance.
Maxi
PS Still studying my array formulas. They make me feel like a real dullard.